Post by turkey
Hopefully
Eye of the Broodmother will drop for you again, because if you aren't having mana issues it's one of the best throughput trinkets disc can get. The crit works perfectly for us as well. In a raid situation, you will have no trouble whatsoever casting every ten seconds to keep the proc stacked.
Illustration of the Dragon Soul, while tougher to get, is fantastic in the same regard.
Your
Forethought Talisman is a good placeholder til you acquire the first two I listed.
Soul of the Dead is nice for the crit alone. The mana return is a bonus.
Scale of Fates could be useful as well. The sp is the reason to take it, but I can think of many occasions where a controlled haste proc could be outstanding (PoH spam on tantrums, frozen blows, etc).
For me, the jury is still out as to the usefulness of the spell power proc on
Pandora's Plea. The argument is that the spell power proc averages out to between 150 and 200 sp throughout the course of a fight.
I find that to be a rosy way of looking at it, however. Instead, as healers, forget the average and consider that in reality, at an unknown time, you will suddenly have 850 more sp. You can toss shields to everyone, load the tank up with a DA (probably well over the 10k max), toss renews too I suppose. Sounds good, right?
Except after the proc, you now have a MINIMUM of 45 seconds without another proc. Hopefully all those spells you just threw a ton of mana at actually did some good. And hopefully a serious damage phase isn't impending.
A sp proc that's down 4 times more than it's up is just not on my wishlist. I prefer knowing how hard my heals and mitigation will hit throughout an encounter, and maximizing that number to the best of my ability.
I doubt you'll find a better combination than the first two trinkets listed. 325 sp and 87 crit should be at the top every disc priest's wishlist.