This site makes extensive use of JavaScript.
Please enable JavaScript in your browser.
Live
PTR
10.2.7
PTR
10.2.6
Beta
Kitty trinket help!
Post Reply
Return to board index
Post by
273446
This post was from a user who has deleted their account.
Post by
SeaOfHoles
I currently use the 333 version of Tia's Grace and the Quicksilver Alchemist Stone, mainly because I looted the one and crafted the other.
I have enough badges to buy the Unsolvable Riddle, but in general, I like passive features as opposed to ones I have to click. In thinking about it though ...
If I was in combat 100% of the time, the Unsolvable Riddle would average out to be a 267.5 (1605*20/120) agility trinket. If I was in combat only 50% of the time, I think that means that it would average to be a 525 (1605*20/60) agility trinket.
So, my thinking has been ...
For a 6 minute boss fight, my permanent 341 agility from Quicksilver Alchemist Stone is better.
For 5 man trash, the Unsolvable Riddle could be better, if you can accept that premise that each encounter lasts 1 minute and another 1 minute expires before the next encounter.
Post by
pelf
I'm pretty sure Tia's Grace and Unheeded Warning are the right choices, there.
Post by
blowtorch
Cat dps increases as weapon dps increases. In many guides you'll find that the weapon slots always tell you to get a weapon with the highest possible dps. So, anything that increases weapon dps is a good thing.
Unheeded Warning
is pretty much BiS (even comparable to heroic modes).
Post by
129046
This post was from a user who has deleted their account.
Post by
476672
This post was from a user who has deleted their account.
Post by
501997
This post was from a user who has deleted their account.
Post by
scaramoush
Mr. Robot is pretty bad, it doesn't take procs on quite a few trinkets into account. It just uses stat weightings to apply value to a trinket without ever modelling the trinkets effectiveness.
To see the actual results, use Mew or Rawr.
Post by
curlymon
Mr. Robot is pretty bad, it doesn't take procs on quite a few trinkets into account. It just uses stat weightings to apply value to a trinket without ever modelling the trinkets effectiveness.
To see the actual results, use Mew or Rawr.
Not true at all... it avg proc's. Go read the info on the site itself. BTW this is the same method Rawr uses.
Post by
476672
This post was from a user who has deleted their account.
Post by
curlymon
I never said Rawr was amazingly on top of things either, lol.
I've had to redo the modeling on the trinkets for boomkin to get things correctly. Any stacking trinket is borked so you need to fix that. Proc trinkets are being undervalued as well. It's easy to run the numbers and see that.
But the biggest thing you will note is simply this. Not a single theorycrafting tool that people frequently use claims to be accurate and ALL of them have a statement in there stating that results should be taken with a grain of salt and with knowledge of the mechanics in mind.
Post by
pelf
Another important thing to keep in mind is that the trinkets in the top 5 BiS list are often on the order of, at the most, a few hundred DPS apart. Sometimes they're literally less than 100 DPS apart.
Post by
476672
This post was from a user who has deleted their account.
Post by
neiljwd
Edit:
Found Mew.
Also this is my
2nd spec, kitty,
not played with it yet, so looking only at theory/ your guys knowledge.
If I were to buy unheeded warning, would it pair best Tia's grace or Unsolvable riddle? Looking only for Heroics really, probably be next tier before I'm ready to raid.
Post by
144872
This post was from a user who has deleted their account.
Post by
neiljwd
Not really.
Fluid Death costs 1650 VP. Not raiding that will take 24 days minimum to earn via heroics. If u can get on every day.
And the benefit of FD over say, Tia's Grace may not as substantial as the DPS increases offered from other VP purchases, 2ptier etc. Not that I know this.
Post by
476672
This post was from a user who has deleted their account.
Post by
curlymon
Mr. Robot is pretty bad, it doesn't take procs on quite a few trinkets into account. It just uses stat weightings to apply value to a trinket without ever modelling the trinkets effectiveness.
To see the actual results, use Mew or Rawr.
Not true at all... it avg proc's. Go read the info on the site itself. BTW this is the same method Rawr uses.
Further info
Decide how you will but this is how they calculate the value of the trinkets.
Post by
Tradu
I'm pretty sure Tia's Grace and Unheeded Warning are the right choices, there.
Yup, Unheeded Warning is BiS and Tia's is better than the trinkets from normal mode raids.
But do try replacing Tia's with Fluid Death, because there isn't much else to spend VP on, and FD is pre-heroic raid BiS
Post by
Tradu
Edit:
Found Mew.
Also this is my
2nd spec, kitty,
not played with it yet, so looking only at theory/ your guys knowledge.
If I were to buy unheeded warning, would it pair best Tia's grace or Unsolvable riddle? Looking only for Heroics really, probably be next tier before I'm ready to raid.
Tia's Grace, because on-use trinkets are generally inferior to stack and procc trinkets, due to the longer cooldown
Post Reply
You are not logged in. Please
log in
to post a reply or
register
if you don't already have an account.