This site makes extensive use of JavaScript.
Please
enable JavaScript
in your browser.
Live
PTR
Classic
TBC
Classic Theme
Thottbot Theme
Stat Weighting Suggestions
Post Reply
Return to board index
Post by
109094
This post was from a user who has deleted their account.
Post by
100179
This post was from a user who has deleted their account.
Post by
pilsner
Hi,
I didn't see
http://www.shadowpriest.com/
listed in the "What are the default weight presets based on?" FAQ entry, so thought I'd recommend it. There is a few "best gear" threads with ranked listings of gear and much discussion on what's "best".
Post by
bwirum
I'd like to be able to weigh different socket colors and meta sockets, not just # of sockets.
Post by
166373
This post was from a user who has deleted their account.
Post by
161182
This post was from a user who has deleted their account.
Post by
bwirum
Aha, like so... hmm.. cool, thanks.
Post by
Emli
Love this feature. I'm one of the many people who requested it, and I find it indispensable.
Couple of things to suggest:
- Force socket colors: I'd like to be able to compare items gemmed in proper colors to items gemmed for max score. 1) Yes, I'm anal like that, 2) it helps to decide which items will lose me the least by gemming in order to meet a meta requirement.
- Stat upper bound: This would be useful for stats that have a theoretical cap of some sort. For example, if I only need 20 more expertise rating to cap out, I'd only want to score up to 20 expertise points on a given item.
- Location of currency item, rather than vendor: This is a more general suggestion, but I thought of it while looking at the weighting output. It's more useful to have the item's location listed as the location of the currency item drop (tier tokens, item trade-ins, etc) than to list the location of the vendor that sells the item.
Post by
Skyfire
- Stat upper bound: This would be useful for stats that have a theoretical cap of some sort. For example, if I only need 20 more expertise rating to cap out, I'd only want to score up to 20 expertise points on a given item.
I'll echo that one, though it would do interesting things to the top-of-the-tiers items. >.>
Post by
Rinkotsu
I haven't read everything here...but...(sorry if this has been said)...
Currently, strength is worth 48 points on the preset. Attack power is worth 24.
Strength gives 2 points of AP each, so obviously that's equal. However, talents that increase strength by a percent, or Blessing of Kings, for instance, should give even MORE points to strength. I suggest perhaps 53 (10% more) instead of 48.
Also not that noticeable, if a DPS warrior needs to tank midfight...strength increases block value.
Post by
rem120
http://www.wowhead.com/?items=4.4&filter=sl=8;ub=1;cr=126;crs=-2323;crv=0;preset=1.pve.fury;gm=3
For the stat weighting selects two red gems when the item has one red and one blue socket.
Post by
Norrec
And ?
The socket bonus is useless for a DPS warrior, that's why the system choose 2 red gems, in order to be more DPS efficiency.
Post by
tiikeri
As i like to count these things myself i'm very happy to see an engine for it. Thank you for this wonderful rating system.
As it is still beta (means it's still a bit unreliable) i'd like to have an option to rank it with the raw score that engine counts.
As a caster working towards hit capped raid gear I use (in this example)
http://www.wowhead.com/?items=4.1&filter=sl=10;ub=9;gm=3;wt=48:49:51;wtv=100:80:60
Now lets take an example from 7th score: Studious Wraps
On help page it is said
"Each weight value is multiplied by an item's stat points and then added together to get the item's total score. "
That would make studious wraps score 25*80 + 40*60 = 4400
and from the sockets & socket bonus 2*8*100 + 4*60 = 1840
(note that it gives 2 yellow-only +8 hit gems to red and blue slot)
Together that makes a weighted score 6240.
a) I would like to have this raw weight score to be shown in Score column (instead of some mysterious 25.00) so that possible miscounts can be found
b) to get that gem slot color bug fixed.
Many thanks for developing this nifty tool!
Post by
peeweesweden
What could be added in the weighting system is the ability to select the weights when you view a single item, to see what score that item has, and compare manually to what you have. It'd make it easier to compare gear of different kinds (guns vs. bows etc.)
Post by
101883
This post was from a user who has deleted their account.
Post by
47926
This post was from a user who has deleted their account.
Post by
Soranthalas
I was looking at some PVP gear for an enhancement shaman when I saw the following:
http://www.wowhead.com/?items=4&filter=sl=8;minle=154;maxle=159;ub=7;cr=79:93:21;crs=1:1:1;crv=0:0:0;ma=1;preset=7.pve.enhance;gm=3
The hunter boots are ranked slightly above the shaman boots. The difference in stats here is:
+30 AP
+16 crit rating
-37 agi
Is the AGI being overvalued, or is the hunter item actually better?
Post by
mech6982
I've got a bug for you that I didn't see skimming this thread (quickly, mind you). When using the weight scale with default values, and using the 'include Rare gem' setting, epic gems are being shown in some cases. As an example, browse Plate Hands with the Protection Paladin weight scale (rare on item quality and included gems). Gauntlets of the Bold will show up with Epic gems instead of blue quality.
Post by
176656
This post was from a user who has deleted their account.
Post by
51192
This post was from a user who has deleted their account.
Post Reply
You are not logged in. Please
log in
to post a reply or
register
if you don't already have an account.
© 2021 Fanbyte
